AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
928
THE PHENOMENON OF ISLAMIC EDUCATION IN MUSLIMS COUNTRIE
Muhammadong
1
, Ichsani
2
, Yasriuddin
3
, Wahyudin
4
, Husriani Husain
5
1,2,3,4
Pendidikan Jasmani Kesehatan dan Rekreasi Universitas Negeri Makassar
1,2,3,4
Jalan Wijaya Kusuma Raya Kota Makassar
5
Institut Turatea Indonesia Kabupaten Jeneponto
5
Kabupaten Jeneponto
1
2
3
4
5
ABSTRACT
The aims of this research is to find out the phenomenon of Islamic education in Muslim
countries. In general, Islamic education is education that is oriented towards the teachings
of the Qur'an and the hadith of the Prophet saw. Islamic education is not only taught in the
formal legal system which is carried out regularly but becomes a teaching that must be
implemented in social life. In Muslim countries, Islamic Education is used as a formal
education that must be completed based on government regulations. It is undeniable that
Islamic education in Muslim countries has adopted a system of modernity so that Islamic
education is oriented towards fulfilling physical needs. However, with this modernity,
Islamic Education takes on a role as a practical function in realizing Islamic teachings as
the absolute truth of Allah SWT.
Keywords: Phenomenon, Islamic, Education, Countrie, Muslims
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 CC BY-SA International License.
INTRODUCTION
Islamic education is an Islamic discipline that has its own charm to study. Islamic
education is a hot subject that is always discussed among educators because it is an object
that must be fulfilled in life. The first verse revealed by Allah swt certainly implies the
obligation to fulfill the elements of education which cannot be separated from the needs of
human life. The word أرقا is a description of the phenomenon of education in classical
times and today which is implemented in various aspects so that human life can be better.
Islamic education seeks to maintain all aspects of human life, including spiritual,
intellectual, imaginative and scientific, both individually and in groups towards goodness
and the attainment of perfection in life. The perfection in question is how to be able to
place himself in a relationship with God, a relationship with the universe and relationships
with fellow human beings.
The process developed in Islamic education contains spiritual, moral, worship,
muamalah elements related to aspects of human life that can be implemented in their lives
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
929
so that they do not go wrong with the intention that the goals to be achieved in Islamic
education are to be able to awaken people and have integrity and balance worldly life and
the hereafter. When connected with students, it is intended that Islamic educators are able
to direct them to prepare provisions for the life of the world and the hereafter but do not
ignore social aspects. Students are expected to be able to become human beings who are
pious, ideal, and have a national perspective. To achieve this goal, Islamic education is no
longer merely pedagogically oriented but requires integrity in advancing an educational
system that is oriented towards technological progress.Talking about modern Arab
countries, synonymous with the Middle East, even the Middle East as countries that are
members of the Arab League. But there are also those who argue that the Middle East is
non-African Arab countries plus Iran and Israel. So that includes the Middle East in this
case are the Arab countries located in North Africa, Egypt, Libya, Morocco, and Algeria.
(Ahmad Caezi, 2006:23).
By the end of the 19th century, Islam had made a change (tajdid) in the shape of the
condition of the Arab people. The term modern or contemporary opposes modern Arab
renewal since the time of struggle, starting with Napoleon Bonaparte's invasion of Egypt in
1798, until the formation and establishment of independent countries in the name of
nationalism. This started since the collapse of the Ottoman caliphate in Istanbul, until now.
(Montgomry W Watt. 1972:130).
The Arab States region had left the administrative power of the Ottoman caliphate. In
general, countries separated themselves due to the influence of the political independence
of imperialist countries. The initial separation was a means for the emergence of Arab
nationalism, because it was a form of liberation from religious ties and turned into
nationalism. They made alterations, falsifications, and a dubious attitude towards the
teachings of Muslims. The transition of Islamic principles, when the Muslims in Arabia
were divided by the colonialists into a separate country. (Abul A'la Al-Maududi, 1990:71).
The aim of the colonialists was none other than that Muslims were not given the
opportunity to study a system that had just been introduced by them. For example, they are
not given the opportunity to exercise ijtihad in the matter of forming a state or they are
closed with reproaches to review it using the rules of ushul fiqh and the law of tasvri' al-
Islamiy. So that there were many reforms in Islamic thought, especially in Arabic. (Husain
Muhammad Haikal., 1996:113).
The historical boundaries of modern Arabic thought, from 1798 to contemporary
Arabia, are not known for certain. It's just that most Arab thinkers themselves consider
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
930
contemporary time (mu'ashirah) to have started since the defeat of the Arabs by Israel in
1967, because that defeat was a defining point in the history of modern Arab politics and
thought. Thus, the Arabs at that time had begun to show their awareness so they had to
criticize (naqd-dzati) for example what happened in Algeria, Islamic life began to dim
somewhat during French colonialism and the religious awareness that occurred in Algeria
strengthened again in 1967. ( Muhsin Mahdi 1971: 65).
This tendency is colored by the fact that many girls have started wearing the hijab as
a sharia dress taught in their religion. This is a countercurrent from the late Colonial
period, when the French tried to distance local women from wearing the hijab. This is one
example of a country whose ideas have been formatted by the colonialists, this momentum
also occurs in other Arab countries such as Egypt, Morocco, Saudi Arabia. (Mahmud
Abbas Al-Aqqad., 1998:64).
The reform of Arab thought was marked by the emergence of Islamic thinkers
Jamaluddin Al-Afgani and Muhammad Abduh with their concept al-sivasah al-ummah
which was elaborated with two terms al-shura. They reasoned that if Arab countries were
to achieve progress, they needed to carry out a revolution so that there would be no
colonization by the West and Europe. in the end the Ottoman government collapsed in the
hands of the invaders, and finally the secular nationalist government by Kemal Ataturk was
established. (Riza Shibud, Drs. et al, 1996:97) As for what pushed Arab thought to hold al-
ishlah due to the many influences of Greek philosophy, diversity has been offered by
Muslims in Arabia, the intervention of colonial thought greatly influenced the souls of
Muslims. (Ali Izzat, Bigiovitc, 1994:179).
From the view above, a statement can be drawn that the development of Islamic
political thought in Arab countries began with the collapse of the Ottoman caliphate which
was later replaced by a secular government. This is due to the entry of colonialists in Arab
countries, and the peak when the Arabs realized that they were defeated, so that today's
Arab thinkers carry out al-ishlah al-fikr (thought reform) in various typologies. (Nurcholish
Madjid., 1994: 36).
The education system in Islamic countries is still far from being ambivalent. The
nature of the ambivalence in question is that the model of implementing religious
education experiences inequality, where on the one hand the religious education
implemented in public schools is only complementary, while the implementation of
education carried out in the Islamic Education system does not develop mastery of
scientific disciplines and skills. There is an assumption that has developed so far that the
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
931
mastery of scientific disciplines and skills is only the work of the general education system
(suwito, 2005)
RESEARCH METHODS
This study uses a qualitative type by explaining the Islamic schema that occurs in
modern Arab countries by revealing the phenomenology of culture, politics and
government. While the scope of the type of research used is by describing the pattern of
depiction of empirical facts according to the appropriate arguments, then an analysis is
carried out to draw an analytic conclusion.
The data collected through library research is taken from books related to the
material presented so that it doesn't get out of the discussion. While the data analysis used
through a qualitative approach aims to analyze the problems under study in order to
connect other facts so that the arguments presented can be right on target while the
quantitative data are presented to strengthen the qualitative data analysis.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Islamic Revival Modernism is a national historical phenomenon that regenerates the
spirit of faith, through thoughts and ideas about change. This revival also brings tests for
Muslims so that it encourages them to look for the causes of the fall and humiliation that
befell them. So moving from this awareness, they find a new awareness. This movement
revived the spirit of Faith towards a revolution called al-Tsaurah. When the Ottoman
government was in the hands of the invaders, Muslims were faced with a system that was
different from Islamic principles, both in the state administration system and in the
economic system. The colonialists' offers to the Islamic Ummah were very contradictory to
classical Islamic teachings. It's just that the Muslim community at that time only responded
as long as it did not conflict with the teachings of the Qur'an and Sunnah. (Crossley,
Michael and Keith Watson, 2003).
The defeat of the Arab countries by the Israelites in 1967 can be said to be the
beginning of the discourse of modern Arabism. The collapse of the caliphate system by the
colonialists was inseparable from the important role of Zionism and Israel. thus leading to
a form of rationalism. As a result, the Arabs changed their perspective on the socio-culture
they faced. Israel's crushing blow made the Arabs ask about their shortcomings. Even
though they have the ability to be relied upon both in terms of human resources and
defense equipment. (Andy Green, eds, 2006).
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
932
The awakening that was discussed by the Arab nation after the humiliation caused by
colonialism is a separate motivation that is echoed by the Islamic Ummah. Islamic
organizations have begun to emerge in order to fight colonialism. The Arab nations have
begun to raise their awareness that Islam is the true teaching and must be practiced. In
order to realize its greatness, it is necessary to form social activities that can educate the
younger generation to become successors in the revival. Mosques must be prospered so
that the message of Islam can be spread according to its purpose. In the political field,
Islamic politics was developed so that Muslims had the spirit of jihad. (A. Marianne
Larsen, 2010).
To realize the revival, Muslims must have brilliant thoughts so that the ideas
produced can be responded to by the colonialists. The Islamic lifestyle must be echoed in
order to avoid European and Western lifestyle tendencies. So the step that must be taken is
to introduce the Arab people's perspective on their own culture through the teachings they
have. In the last two decades, this problem has become a hot issue and received a positive
response. In its development, the issue of modernity has become an important agenda in
shaping the civilization of contemporary Arab thought so that it can give birth to a
typology of contemporary Arabic thought. The typology in question is, (UNESCO Institute
for Statistics, 2012).
1. Transformational typology. That is a typology that can represent Arab thinkers
who radically propose the process of transforming Muslim Arab society from traditional
patriarchal culture to a rational and scientific society. This typology is commonly called
social transformation in which they reject religious perspectives and mystical tendencies
that are not based on practical reason and consider past religions and traditions to be no
longer relevant to today's demands. This group was first represented by Arab thinkers from
Christian circles such as; Shibli Shumayl, Farah Antun and Salamah Musa Later, it is
currently continued by thinkers who are mostly oriented towards Marxism such as Thayvib
Tayzini, Abdullah Laroui and Mahdi Amil, besides there are other liberal thinkers such as
Fuad Zakariyya, Adonis, Zaki Nadjib Mahmud, Adil Daher and Qustantine Zurayq.
2. Reformist typology. That is a typology that requires reform with various new
interpretations that are more lively and more in line with the demands of the times.
Specifically, this group is divided into two tendencies, namely the tendency of
reconstructive thinkers, by looking at tradition from a rebuilding perspective ('adah bunivat
minjadid), meaning that the traditions of a society (religion) are still alive and can continue
to be accepted, so it must be rebuilt anew. . This is done like;, Jamaluddin al-Afghani, and
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
933
Muhammad Abduh. In the present era, it can be found in reformist thinkers such as Hassan
Hanafi, Muhammad Imarah, Muharmad Ahmad Khalafalah, Hasan Saab and Muhammed
Nuwayhi. This group differs from the traditionalist group, which emphasizes the
"restatement" method. The second trend is the emergence of reformistic thinking using
deconstructive methods. That is a method based on a new phenomenon for contemporary
Arab thinkers. Because these thinkers were heavily influenced by the French "post"
structuralist movement and several other postmodernism figures, such as Levis Straus,
Derrida, Foucoult. The thinkers at the forefront of this group are Mohammed Arkoun and
Mohammed Abid Jabiri. Both of these reformistic typological tendencies have the same
goals and ideals that differ only in their methods.
3. The totalistic ideal typology, namely a typology which views that idealists towards
Islamic teachings must be totalistic so that the results achieved can be more perfect. This
group is very committed to the religious aspects of Islamic culture. The project of this type
is to revive Islam as a religion, culture and civilization. They reject foreign intervention
that comes from the West because according to them Islam itself is very perfect which can
regulate the order of social, political, economic life etc. This group wants to return to
Islamic teachings, namely the Koran and hadith as a way of life so that they can find the
path of truth. Method of approach to turats. Traditionalists can be equated, but the
difference between them is that this group does not deny modernity, because what has been
produced by modernity through science and technology is nothing more than what was
achieved by Muslims in the era of the greatness of Islam in ancient times. These thinkers
are represented by Hasan al-Banna, Sayyid Qutb, Said Hawwa.
From some of the typologies above, one can see a picture of Islam in Arab countries
in general, and in particular the movement of the discourse of the thoughts of Muslims in
the Arab nation. This phenomenon can be said to be a crisis of political thought in Arab
countries (azmat al-fikr al-siyasiy fi aalam al-arabiy), as many Arab Islamic thinkers have
written about today. They say that the collapse of the Islamic government has been
replaced by a secular state government and many adopted the colonial state government
system. The government that used to be godly, has now been replaced by a godless
government. "commentary Hassan al-Banna released by Abdu Rahman in an article." And
there are many more Islamic ideologies that have been replaced by Western ideologies,
such as liberalism, capitalism, socialism and Western-style democracy. All of these are
crises that hit the Arab countries today.
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
934
However, the phenomenon of realizing peaceful Arab Countries will not be realized
if the unity between them is not carried out. The emergence of sects among them will open
up opportunities for colonialism to enter, which can colonize the minds and bodies of
Muslims. So to realize these pure ideals, it is necessary to unite voices to realize the
independence of a nation due to liberalism and capitalism pioneered by democracy in the
West. However, Islam is a religion that conforms to circumstances so that the ideas raised
can be abstracted between absolutism and relative reality. The ideas raised can be
abstracted in sharia teachings and doctrines so that their universal values are illustrated. In
Islamic teachings that reality is material and situational events that surround human life.
Meanwhile, religiosity is a psychic belief in absolute doctrines, and historical endeavors
are attempts to bring reality closer to doctrines, contextualize faith in the most ideal form
of reality, and then strive continuously for truth to develop religion towards the point of
ideal perfection.
The State of Medina is a regional reality with an international perspective so that it
can be an example for other countries, especially Middle Eastern countries. This country
has transcended the realities of its time, because its inhabitants believe that they are part of
the chain of the previous Islamic community led by the Apostles. Psychologically, Medina
has also transcended its regional reality, because its inhabitants have been actively
involved in international conflicts with the Persians and Romans, especially in economic,
political and religious conflicts. The State of Medina with its conditions turned out to be
able to strengthen the Arab world and all of humanity as a bias and a means of integration.
The causal factor is because the Arabs have a divine mission.
Education in Muslim countries applies a religious education system, this is because
Islam was born in the Arabian Peninsula and was first spread in that region. The education
system in Muslim countries has a distinctive feature, namely that Islamic studies is part of
the education system in addition to scientific and social studies and the government
provides free education to all levels of education so that students' interest in learning is
higher and it prioritizes quality. (Yael Navaro Yashin, 2002).
It's just that the educational model applied is found to be similar to the education
system in Indonesia which regulates the education level system starting from the level of
early childhood education, middle class education, and education at tertiary institutions.
The pattern of education in Islamic countries makes it very easy for people to access
education because schools are provided free of charge, starting from public schools and
private schools. The educational model places more emphasis on the religious field
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
935
considering that the majority of the population is Muslim. In the learning process in class,
the men's room is separated from the women's room as a feature of the applied Islamic
education system.
The Islamic education system in Türkiye is certainly different from that implemented
in other Islamic countries. Türkiye tends to be somewhat modern and liberal in
implementing the Islamic education system. The pattern of renewal of Islamic education in
Turkey is carried out in three aspects, namely the first pattern of renewal of Islamic
education which is oriented towards modern education. This orientation refers to the
Western system which has succeeded in advancing education in the science and technology
sector. Of course this understanding was adopted by Turkey in the education system
because the success of the West cannot be separated from the progress of Islam in the
classical era which is now controlled by the West. Both are oriented towards the
purification of Islam. This orientation wants to restore the purity of Islam as a teaching
revealed by Allah SWT without any elements of religious dualism. This understanding
considers that the weakness of Islam is due to negligence in accommodating various
understandings that have emerged without filtering so that the main foundation of the faith
can be crippled through misguided understanding. The third is oriented towards
Nationalism. This orientation assumes that the glory of nationalism can be achieved if it is
carried out independently without the interference of other nations. This understanding
assumes that local culture and foreign culture must be united so that the strength of
Muslims can be maintained based on the conditions that occur.
Islamic education implemented in Egypt can be said to be very advanced because the
interest of Muslims is very high to continue their education in that country. The
government removed the financing system in education so that students were not burdened
with the study budget because everything was borne by the government. It is on the basis
of this motivation that the spirit of learning is getting higher. The Islamic education model
is managed based on the curriculum of the Ministry of Education. The issues raised in
theological-based educational materials focus on studying the verses of the Qur'an and the
Hadith of the Prophet.
CONCLUSION
Before the discourse of Arab thought was divided, it eventually formed nationalism.
At first they were united, but when they were colonized, they were divided, and almost all
of their colonial thoughts had been adopted. Their forms of resistance in terms of western
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
936
thought, both liberal, capitalist and western-style democracy, have all been filtered out by
the Arabs because they are from various countries in the Middle East region and are aware
of their oppression. On the other hand, the Arab countries did not want to be said to be left
behind by generations, so they carried out a very in-depth evaluation to harmonize the two
sides of knowledge, namely classical knowledge attained by Muslims and modern
knowledge through science and technology as seen today.
SUGGESTION
Thanks are extended to the Academy of Education journal (AoEJ) for publishing this
article so that this paper can be used as a recommendation in the study of Islamic education
in Muslim countries. Suggestions and criticism will be improved in the future for the
perfection of this paper.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Al-Aqqad. Abbas Mahmud. 1998. Al-islam Da’wah aalamiyah wa Maqalat al-Ukhra. (t.th.
Penerbit al-Maktabat al-Ashriyah. Bairut)
Bigiovitc. Ali Izzat, 1994. Islam between Eastand west. Diterjemahkan oleh Muhammad
Yusuf Adas. Dalam judul Al-islam Baina Al-syarq wa al-garb (Cet:1. Majjalah al-
Nur. Quwait. Januari.
Caezi, Ahmad, 2006. Syi’ah political thought, diterjemahkan ke dalam bahasa Indonesia
oleh Ali Syahab dengan Judul “Agama politik”. Cet. I;;Jakarta:Citra.
Crossley, Michael and Keith Watson, (2003) Comparative and International Research in
Education; Globalisation, Context and Difference, London and New York:
RoutledgeFalmer.
Green, Andy (eds.), 2006. Education, Equality and Social Cohesion; A Comparative
Analysis, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Haikal. Muhammad Husain, 1996. Al-Mufawadhat al-Sirriyah Baina al-Arab wa Israil
(Cet: VI Dar al-Syuruk. Cairo Egypt November.
Larsen, Marianne A., (2010) New Thinking in Comparative Education; An Introduction
dalam Marianne A. Larsen (ed.) New Thinking in Comparative Education, Taipe:
Sense Publishers.
Madjid. Nurcholish, 1994. Khasanah Intelektual Islam, Jakarta: Bulan Bintang.
Al-Maududi, Abul A’la, 1990. The Islamic Law and constitusion, diterjemahkan ke dalam
Bahasa Indonesia oleh Asep Hikmat dengan Judul “Hukum dan konstitusi politik
Islam”. Cet.I; Bandung:Mizan.
Mahdi. Muhsin, 1971. Ibn Khaldun Philosofi of History, Chicago: The University of
Chicago Press.
Shibud, Riza, Drs.dkk, 1996. Profil Negera-negara Timur Tengah (Cet: 1. PT. Dunia
Pustaka Jaya, Jakarta.
AoEJ: Academy of Education Journal
Vol. 14 No 2 Tahun 2023
937
Suwito, ed (2005) Sejarah Sosial Pendidikan Islam (Jakarta: Kencana, 2005).
UNESCO Institute for Statistics, (2012) Global Education Digest 2012; Comparing
Education Statistics Across The World, Canada: UNESCO Institute for Statistics.
Watt. W. Montgomry, 1972. Islamic Philosophi and Theology, Endinburg: Endinburg
University Press.
Yashin, Yael Navaro, (2002) Faces of The State; Secularism and Public Life in Turkey,
United Kingdom: Princeton University Press.